18 responses so far ↓

• 1 John // Sep 26, 2012 at 8:26 pm

  Mine favorite game was (and still is) Fallout 2

• 2 Herr_Alien // Sep 27, 2012 at 1:57 am

  Welcome back Paul.

  @Cryptic calls for new MMO review system
  Hmm, how can you say “f*ck you” in a nice way … Let’s try “I’d like to have intercourse with you”.

  Then same should go for Diablo III and all games that keep changing due to bug fixes and patches.
  Come on, if you dropped the ball in the time interval you had the game reviewed, tough luck.

  As an alternative, we should delay reviewing an MMO until at least 6 months have passed since released. Sure, you won’t have a potentially good review to increase the hype and sales figure, but it’ll be a fair review system, right?

  So, you Cryptic idiots, make your mind: what do you want, a fair but delayed review that will do nothing to help with your sales or an early review that might be skewed? Think about it, being skewed is not really a bad thing, if you have enough money, he he he …

  Jonah, I would love to have score-less reviews. When somebody asks me about a game, I tell them what I liked and what I didn’t like. I’m not telling them it’s a 8.34 grade game.

  @Wii U gamepad won’t be sold separately at launch
  Yay, pricing flexibility FTW! Wait, what?
  So they can live without the extra cash? Or is it that the company has no idea on how to price it? Hmm …

  @me playing SNES games: guys, you keep forgetting I’m a PC (ha!). We have emulators …

  @QOTW: Not for the contest though, I have very little time to play. So, favorite game of the 90’s: Quake III, launched in December 1999. Screw Starcraft or Red Alert, at least Quake III’s engine ended up in a huge amount of other games. And even today, I still find the game (both multiplayer and the single player with bots) to be very entertaining.

• 3 SgtRicko // Sep 27, 2012 at 6:38 am

  Unless it’s some massive update like World of Warcraft does, it’s impractical to repeatedly update game reviews: lots of folks just don’t have the time to make it consistent or practical. For example, World of Tanks recently released a large update that drastically improved the graphics, added new tanks, a physics system, updated/new maps, and a ton of balance changes, but does it deserve a re-review? I don’t think so. It’s still the same game at it’s core.

  You can’t have a long-time player make the reviews themselves either, because they’re either going to ruthlessly flame it (like most typical forum posts :/ ), or justify whatever faults it still has as being intentional, part of it’s charm, necessary for game balance, etc.

  And lastly… do updated reviews really even matter? Think about it: the only way an update to an MMO is going to gain a large group of new is if it does something huge and newsworthy, otherwise it’s probably only going to re-attract longtime fans or those who were undecided.

  And tell me, what exactly is it that Star Trek Online added? I haven’t even seen a single advertisement for it, let alone forum hype for it anywhere, so why exactly would I be enticed to jump aboard, even if it’s free?

• 4 The Baron // Sep 27, 2012 at 9:02 am

  My favorite is probably Donkey Kong Country 2. It’s some of the finest platforming you’ll find, period.

• 5 onyhow // Sep 27, 2012 at 10:35 am

  I can definitely understand about the want to do on 1 year later review…but I think it depends a lot on if there’s a lot of changes or not…

  My favourite game? Warzone 2100…the design-it-yourself unit is a cool system that’s still underused in RTS today, and it’s also one of the first games to look good on full 3d….

• 6 Shawn // Sep 27, 2012 at 2:11 pm

  My favorite game in the 90’s….would have to be Half-Life 1 for the PC. Still the best FPS these days and it has aged very well. And of course, the first game that put Valve on the map. Such a historical and important game in the industry

• 7 Mase // Sep 28, 2012 at 3:16 am

  Easy favourite: Total Annihilation

  Still think it is one of the greatest RTS’s of all time

• 8 Johnny // Sep 28, 2012 at 6:50 pm

  My favorite game from the 90’s is Cruis’n USA

• 9 oasis789 // Sep 29, 2012 at 3:03 am

  Fave 90s game: Dune 2!

• 10 Giant Robots // Sep 29, 2012 at 7:26 am

  Star Wars Rogue Squadron on the N64 from ’98. Looked great back then, and still looks great now. Tons of missions and unlockable content. FIGHT IMPERIAL SCUM IN A 1998 BUICK.

• 11 Jed // Sep 29, 2012 at 12:10 pm

  Not sure if this counts but Planescape Torment is one of my favorites ever and it came out in 99. But its mainly an all time favorite for all games ever made.

• 12 Arnaud M // Sep 30, 2012 at 10:59 am

  Gonna totally agree with Paul and go with Link to the Past.. That’s the golden age of SNES

• 13 HanzKrebs // Sep 30, 2012 at 11:28 am

  PAUL ON DRUGS, YEY!
  next step: drunken podcast!

  @Cryptic calls for new MMO review system:
  it would have good and bad backlashes, good being “real time” scores, wich mean better and more accurate reviews. the bad being that other games that get patches would require the same scoring system, here as an example, my beloved battlefield 3, wich got several paches trough time and got significantly better, UI and gameplay wise, would get a significantly better score multiplayer wise, and such requests from all sort of games that get patched and better would demand a huge amount of time and man/hours work to make the score system accurate and up-to-date.
  in a utopic perfect gaming world, this would be awesome, but will not happen to all games, but MMOs are different and it would be possible, it is a very good idea.

  @PS3 version of Black Ops 2 includes optional hi-res texture install:
  why is CoD still a thing? oh… yeah, the money… nvm, moving on….

  @Wii U gamepad won’t be sold separately at launch:
  Nintendo, go home, you’re drunk. who in their right minds would not sell separate controllers as well??? i am sure nintendo have some good reasons, but if they do not reveal them, it will be the same as no reason at all!

  @QOTW:
  i’m caught between a rock and a hard place: Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped or Half-Life.
  I’m more inclined towards HL because of the recent release of the free 2 play black mesa remake, wich is as equally awesome! so, yeah, Half-Life!

  good recovery paul!

• 14 Maxim // Sep 30, 2012 at 3:51 pm

  @QOTW: original Diablo, that was a game changer for me. Blizzard never really got the sequels right though.

• 15 EMP // Sep 30, 2012 at 10:24 pm

  XCOM ufo defense is my favorite game from the 90s, which is why I’m so psyched for the new one.

• 16 Jeremy // Oct 1, 2012 at 9:33 am

  People want scores in their reviews. Whether they use it for Good or Evil or to make buying decisions or to validate an opinion they already have, why force them into something they don’t find as useful? MetaCritic isn’t doing anything immoral or even questionable – just aggregating data that’s out there. If someone were really interested, they could do it themselves.

  Re-reviews aren’t a bad idea, but I don’t think they would be much more than a curiosity. The “retro” writing community will probably explore the big picture later.

  MY FAVORITE 90s GAME: Master of Magic! Fantasy, strategy, Civ… It practically held me captive for a couple of years. I still whistle the overworld theme. So great. There have been some really great spiritual successors since then. Age of Wonders, and I even like Elemental. But Master of Magic got into my blood like nothing else.

• 17 Jordan // Oct 1, 2012 at 4:51 pm

  Sorry ai coukdn’t make it, my dad passed away so I was off doing some un-fun stuff. Should be back tonight though.

  I think when it comes to re-reviewing MMOs (or any game, really) the perfect opportunity pops up when an expansion or DLC comes out. Borderlands became a much, much stronger game after all four DLC were avaialable and the Game of the Year edition merits a stronger review than the original release.

• 18 Freddy // Oct 3, 2012 at 4:09 pm

  Favorite 90s game: System Shock 2. That was one scary game!

Leave a Comment